Despite Trump’s liability in these prior cases, Carroll’s victory was incredibly gratifying for those observers who wanted Trump held accountable for his deplorable and corrupt actions. This suit was against him as an individual with no corporate fig leaf. Carroll and the other 20 women who accused Trump of sexual assault were validated. In the other cases in which Trump has been found liable, the punishment he received for his actions seemed distant from the pain that he caused. Through her courage and persistence, Carroll ensured Trump’s punishment was as personal as the pain he caused.
The pain Trump causes is usually impersonal. Some of Trump’s sexual assaults seemed impersonal to him, even though they were horrendous for the women he targeted. When Trump, laughing and joking, lured Carroll into a Bergdorf Goodman dressing room to sexually assault her, she represented a symbol through which he could prove his power. Trump’s defense was that he did not know that woman; she was not his type. An incident with Kristin Anderson, a woman Trump did not know, occurred in a nightclub. Sitting beside her, Trump touched her vagina through her underwear without speaking. In another instance, Trump sexually assaulted a woman he did not know on an airplane. Jessica Leeds testified in the Carroll trial that when she was seated next to him, Trump kissed her, groped her breast, and tried to put his hand up her skirt. These acts were not to provide him with sexual gratification. They were to increase his sense of power.